Journo Course Costs Can Be ‘Huge Barrier’

Oli Rahman

Oliver Rahman – studying hard for media law

NCTJ trainee Oliver Rahman stresses the importance of formal training but questions the costs…

Ex Sun-Editor Kelvin Mackenzie expressed his views on journalism education in 2011 by saying: “I’d shut down all the journalism colleges today. If you want to be a print journalist you should go straight from school and join the local press.”

To some extent I agree. I’ve already written about how much I love local journalism, and the way it can be a brilliant training ground for budding reporters.

But the idea that formal journalism education is a waste of time has problems. Being taken on as a trainee directly after school with minimal qualifications, as Kelvin was, seems unlikely in today’s world.

I take his point about how colleges have become a great business model for semi-retired journalists, and in some cases are exploitative.

But the world is less forgiving of reporters in the wake of Leveson, and much more is expected of them.

As an editor you can’t just send a person with no understanding of media law or shorthand to do court reporting. You might end up on the wrong end of a defamation lawsuit.

Nor can you expect a high standard of news copy from someone without some formal training.

Mackenzie’s assumption that journalism education focuses too much on theory is something I disagree with, as my own experience of the NCTJ suggests that it is more practical than theoretical.

Education is never a bad thing, although affordability can be a huge barrier.

Less privileged kids stand little chance of breaking through; their parents might be unwilling to support them through endless stints of unpaid work experience, or perhaps they are unable to afford the training.

Take for example The Guardian’s masterclasses. A feature writing course costs £400, and an investigative journalism course £500.

It seems hard to justify these prices, and there’s no doubt that they would only be available to a privileged minority.

It would be brilliant if newspapers were still prepared to snaffle up the smart school leavers and train them up into premier news hounds.

Getting onto a traineeship with the BBC or a great local title is what most people would do if they had the opportunity, but with the dramatic increase in the number of hungry university graduates, this can never be guaranteed.

Mackenzie would be right if we lived in a perfect world.

What do you think? How important is formal journalism training, and are the costs always justified? Tweet us your views @Journograds or leave a comment below

Local Journalism ‘Great Training Ground’

Dddd

Oliver Rahman brushes up on karaoke skills during his year in Japan

Graduate Oliver Rahman is currently training at News Associates, one of the UK’s biggest NCTJ schools. He tells us what he makes of the course so far, and describes the merits of regional journalism…

I studied Japanese and Italian in Manchester, and spent much of my time in Japan blogging, writing for a local magazine and perfecting my karaoke talents.

My summer in Italy was spent smoking and learning new Italian swear words. I was in Perugia, where the Amanda Knox trial (Foxy Knoxy, as she was known) was taking place.

For any wannabe journo, the sight of a real press mob is pretty damn exciting. Particularly if it involves Italian TV reporters, who are always entertainingly flamboyant.

After graduation I organized a stint at my local paper, the Wells Journal. I loved it. Stories about lead thefts from church roofs or milk fixing scandals are a lot of fun.

Some trainees would hesitate to admit that they love local journalism, but I think that the regional press can be a great training ground.

After a few months working in London for a TV company, I decided to pack it in and just get onto an NCTJ with News Associates in Wimbledon.

I’d been to one of their open days in Manchester two years ago and it had left a lasting impression. It consisted of a workshop simulating a live news room.

You get given basic facts (a fictional explosion in Birmingham), and as press releases/news clips with new facts keep appearing, you have to rejig your copy and try to fit in all the new info before the deadline.

Wannabe journos get a chance to interview sources by phone, and at the end file their copy like pros. Really good fun, if a bit stressful. And as it’s free, I’d definitely recommend it.

News Associates’ entrance exam is divided into a general knowledge section, a writing test (something to do with exploding hotdogs), and a few basic data questions.

Then there was an interview in which Richard Parsons, course director, sat me down and asked me a few questions about my portfolio. I remember little about it except for some serious mustache stroking that gave away his status as a true newsroom veteran.

As well as the formal classes in media law, shorthand and reporting, part of the course involves a placement.

I’m at the Ealing Times with another trainee, so we’ll be covering all those important local issues: firefighting squirrels, water skiiing budgies and maybe even some real news.

Are you currently on an NCTJ course? If so, how has it helped you? Or are you thinking about doing one? Feel free to post your comments or questions below.

Disabilities And The Journalism Job Hunt

Disabled journalist Tamara Marshall highlights the difficulties of pursuing a career in the industry, and offers words of advice for those in a similar situation…

Graduates worry about future job prospects, but those with disabilities will fear the competition of the journalistic market more than most.

I should know – living with a hearing impairment, I suffer these fears constantly.

I am studying for an NCTJ diploma in Magazine Journalism, but sometimes I am doubtful about my chances of success in the industry.

Daily tasks such as using a telephone and communicating in loud, busy environments are a constant struggle – yet these are considered central tasks to the role of a journalist.

My pessimism is compounded by the overwhelming lack of advice and information available to aspiring journalists with disabilities.

Often there is a preconception that a disability – whether a disfigurement, mobility issue or problematic condition – presents an obstacle to employment.

It’s a harsh reality that disabled journalists are conditioned by social stigmas and swamped with fears of labelling in the workplace.

Yet ultimately, journalists, disabled or not, should be recognised and valued for what they can do, rather than what they cannot.

Negative perceptions and lack of representation

A main problem with journalism today is the small number of disabled people working in the industry. Think about it – how many disabled journalists can you name?

Back in 2003, Disability Now published a report to expose this absence, highlighting the lack of research conducted on the issue.

It raised concern about the limited aids provided for disabled journalists, particularly for those working in radio and television, and the small number of disabled students applying to study journalism at higher education.

Essentially, it identified that many students were deterred from entering the industry due to a fear of being labelled.

Journalists with disabilities face daily social stigmas and discriminatory attitudes.  Among these is the idea that disabled journalists are unable to perform in the workplace as efficiently and competently as an employee without disabilities.

There is also the deep-seated perception that disabled journalists should, and would, prefer to be assigned to cover disability issues. This is not the case.

Certainly we could report with great understanding and insight, but quite frankly I feel that living with my disability is enough as it is, let alone allowing it to dominate my career.

I cannot deny that I have found great comfort and confidence from engaging with my hearing loss by expressing it in my writing, but I would never aim to become a one-subject disability journalist.

Principally, in order for disabled journalists to gain more presence in the media industry, there needs to be a major cultural shift in the media’s attitude towards them.

Finding your niche and working with your disabilities

The rise of online media has been a huge asset to disabled journalists. Today many of us are able to pursue our passion for writing by building a presence online as freelancers.

Freelancing has propelled disabled journalists into the writing world, enabling us to avoid the pressures of the workplace, where our skills and value as employees may be questioned.

I caught up with Richard MacEachran, a disabled journalist who writes for the The Guardian.

He told me that freelancing provides him with an escape from the judgemental attitudes and negativity he has experienced as a result of his facial disfigurement.

He said: “This field of journalism offers a chance for me to work in an environment where my disfigurement becomes irrelevant. I feel I have more to offer and am more likely to be valued, whereas in the corporate sector I might be fighting against the desire to conform to an image.”

Other disabled journalists may choose to use their experiences to help represent the variations in modern society.

Just take a look at the Hampshire based radio station, Radio Enham.

Launched in 2011, it communicates with the disabled community, particularly those of the Enham Trust, a charity offering specialist support services to the disabled.

Aptly describing itself as “a radio station for disabled people by disabled people,” Radio Enham gives disabled clients the chance to become involved in journalism.

I spoke with Hannah Cave, a media and journalism graduate currently interning there.

She explained: “Radio Enham has given clients responsibility and independence to run projects with minimal support. It effectively demonstrates how disabled people can be journalists, overcoming stereotypes and expectations by pushing themselves to overcome their difficulties when they are put in front of a microphone.”

My advice is that graduates and students, disabled or not, should make the most of what they CAN do. If you have passion and determination to be a journalist, fight for your place. Strive to overcome negative attitudes and remember – it’s your ABILITY that matters.

Tamara Marshall is a Swansea University Media Studies graduate studying for an NTCJ diploma in Magazine Journalism. She has recently started a blog documenting her experiences as an aspiring disabled journalist

Is Doing A Masters In Journalism ‘Worth It’?

Broadcast journalism MA graduate Dan Kilpatrick weighs up the value of postgraduate degrees…

Whilst I agree that there is no substitute for experience, I’ve heard it suggested that work experience is for the committed, while journalism courses are for the undecided.

In other words: postgraduate courses are a great way to test the water and decide whether or not a career as a Hack is really for you.

I strongly disagree with this; I would only recommend enrolling in a course if you are committed to a career in journalism. Courses are highly vocational and are not the place to discover that the industry isn’t for you.

If you have some half-baked idea that you want to be a journo, try as hard as possible to get some experience before deciding on a course. It would be better to realise that you can’t stand broadcasting whilst working as a runner at Sky than halfway through a heinously expensive journalism course.

While it’s never awful to have an extra qualification, the skills attained on the course are only transferable to a limited number of other industries – PR for instance – and you may find yourself pigeon-holed. In a moment of despair recently, I sent my CV to a number of financial recruiters but they all said the same thing: I was trained for a career in journalism, not finance.

Finding a job

There is little doubt in my mind that completing a course will help you take the first step towards a career in journalism. I have friends who claim that only work experience matters but I see job adverts daily stating a qualification in journalism is ‘preferable’ or even ‘essential’, as employers seek to dilute the pool of applicants.

I also have a friend who was employed at a leading tabloid but told to do an intensive NCTJ-recognised course before she could be considered for promotion.

Both jobs I’ve had since finishing my MA have been a direct result of it. Kelvin MacKenzie, erstwhile editor of The Sun – a fine and honourable man – claimed he would close down all the journalism colleges, suggesting it was ‘a knack’ rather than a profession.

Strangely, he employed me and 11 others, all of whom had some form of postgraduate journalism or broadcasting degree, on his new TV channel.

My second job, as a writer on an investment magazine, came despite having shown utterly no interest in finance until then. Not even an economics GCSE or A-Level.

The editor was simply looking for someone who had learned the necessary skills and could write; knowledge of finance would come later.

As a general rule, the more creative or specific the form of journalism you want to get into, the less important the qualification becomes. When applying for sport or fashion roles, you will need to be able to show a demonstrable and passionate interest in the field.

Few budding hacks are able to demonstrate a passionate interest in finance or business for example, so securing these types of roles will depend more on your qualifications.

Providing a framework

While I am loath to agree with MacKenzie, the man has a point. The course won’t make you a journalist but it will provide a framework to help you along the way.

Shorthand, if offered, should be learnt at all costs (there are very few shorthand teachers out there and this is one thing you’re unlikely to learn on the job). Other skills including interview technique, filming and editing are also likely to prove useful.

However, many of the subjects covered – news writing for instance – can only be perfected with experience in a working environment. It took over a month of writing three to four investment news stories a day before my editor was happy that I had it sussed.

My course did encourage me to write regularly but budding journalists should be doing this anyway. Ultimately, the two most important things I took away from the MA were increased confidence and, ironically, the realisation of how essential work experience is.

It is not enough to simply complete a curriculum. In order to be a success, you have to be constantly poking around for stories, thinking of original ideas, seeking work experience where possible and writing.

Simply no substitute

I’ll say it again: there is simply no substitute for experience. I find it hard to believe that had I managed to get a job as a tea boy or runner at a broadcaster or newspaper, rather than enrolling on the course, I’d be worse off than I am now.

The two main tenants of journalism – as I see it – are talking to people and writing creatively. With online blogs and the advent of smart-phones (with recording/filming technology) it has never been easier to do both these things. If you are committed to a career in journalism, all you really need is a computer and enough determination.

That said, journalism has always been a difficult industry to break into and today the entire job market is more saturated than ever. In such an environment, employers – including turncoats like MacKenzie – are increasingly recognising the value of such courses.

Ultimately, if you are fully committed to being a hack, a course will teach you skills helpful in the workplace and may give you the edge in finding a job – but it won’t turn you into a journalist.

Dan Kilpatrick is a Wesminster University Broadcast MA graduate and freelance sports journalist